This year has started off with some changes for me, well one really big change that had some trickle down effects. In February after 9 years I started a new job at a different library. My focus is now different and as such I am not visiting and working with children as often. This also means I don't have to read as many children's books to give monthly book talks for grades K-5. I'll be honest this is a blessing in some ways. There are times I am not in the mood for a juvenile book or sometimes I will read a book and think it's a great book but it's not the best for a book talk with a group of students with varied reading and maturity levels. Plus the big bonus is I have time to read a lot more for fun and not think about how I would talk about the book or use it in a program.
One book I have wanted to read for only a few years, despite it being published in 1943, is A Tree Grows in Brooklyn by Betty Smith. This is a coming of age story set just after the turn of the 20th century. I listened to the audiobook and became so engrossed in the book that I also had a copy of the book for those times when an audiobook was not appropriate. I could not get enough of Francie Nolan's story.
Francie was an American born in the United States as were her parents. This is an important distinction because most of Francie's classmates were sons and daughters of immigrants or even immigrants themselves. In the current state of our country this book took on even more significance for me because some of the same issues faces immigrants today.
Certainly going to college was not the norm as many children did not even attend high school due to the need for children to work to help support the family. In many families both parents worked though the mother might work by taking in washing, sewing, or cleaning homes in order to take care of her children and home. While the jobs have changed, most households now have two working parents. So it seems that one hundred years have passed and some things have not changed.
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn is Francie's story but it is also the story of life in the tenements of Brooklyn. Life was not easy but people made the best of what they had and learned to live with little they had. Each family had its challenges, for Francie's it was the fact that her father was an alcoholic and had difficulty holding a job. Francie's mother and grandmother both valued education and knew that was the key to getting out of the tenements and the hard life. Francie worked hard and was smart, but she learned about life not just at school. She learned from everyone around her including her aunts, grandmother, parents, and the neighborhood business owners.
This is one of those books that will stay with you and make you think. Even weeks after finishing it, I still think about what life was like and have even done some research to see how accurately life was portrayed. I think about what I would have done in Francie's shoes. Would I have been as strong as her? Would I have had her courage?
I also think about whether the same opportunities exist now. Can someone living in the projects work hard, dedicate themselves to their education, and improve where they are in life? The answer to all of these questions are I Don't Know. I would like to think so, but it seems as if there are more and different obstacles now that there were in the early 1900's.
If you have the opportunity, please take the time to read A Tree Grows in Brooklyn. It shows as life changes, it stays the same and that there is always a group that looked down on. That group may change but we as humans don't seem to be capable of treating all groups of people the same. We might discriminate based on gender, ethnicity, national origin, religion, ability, or for some other reason not yet determined.
I hope you enjoy A Tree Grows in Brooklyn as much as I did.
Happy Reading!

No comments:
Post a Comment