Wednesday, November 16, 2016

To read the book or to watch the movie?

I'm one of those people that believes the book is always better than the movie. That doesn't mean I don't watch the movies.

If I know a book has been made into a movie or a movie is based on a book I will try to read the book first. I used to watch the movie first so I could enjoy the movie and then enjoy the book even more. The problem with this is the movie put into my mind how things should look and it took away from my imagination. Now I read the book first and then critique the movie when I see it.

Some movies stay true to the book and some do not. Most of the time the movie can't include every detail of the book but can still capture the story which is all I can hope for.

I'm a big fan of the Harry Potter books and movies. Even though in the books it is repeatedly stated Harry has green eyes and Daniel Radcliffe has blue eyes that becomes a minor detail as Mr. Radcliffe does a great job being Harry. The special effects are phenomenal in these movies and the movies stay true to the books and capture the story of Harry Potter.

The Lightning Thief (book 1 of Percy Jackson & the Olympians) by Rick Riordan is a great book and I love it. The movie Percy Jackson & the Olympians: the Lightning Thief is a terrible adaptation of the book BUT it is a good movie IF you don't compare it to the book or haven't read the book. These are two different stories. The second movie, Sea of Monsters sticks closer to the book which means it doesn't tie-in well to the first movie.

There is only one time I can say I thought the movie was better or enhanced the book. Shutter Island by Dennis Lehane was a little confusing to read but the movie by the same name starring Leonardo DiCaprio helped make things clearer. Also, the way the movie was done was less confusing and therefore better than the book.

SPOILER ALERT
Then there is the movie that I hated! My Sister's Keeper is a movie based on the Jodi Picoult book of the same title. HELLO!!!! You can't change the ending! I know movies change parts of books and even change endings all the time but the ending is this case was key to the story. The movie didn't do the book or story justice with a different ending.

So, what movie butchered a book you love? Or do you have a movie that stayed true to the book and was also awesome? Do you watch the movie if you read the book? Let me know below in the comments? 

Happy reading (and watching)!

No comments:

Post a Comment